By Dr. Chen Chengyu
The National Association for Hong Kong and Macao Studies recently held a thematic seminar. Director Xia Baolong clearly stated that all government departments must “break down the barriers created by entrenched interests and resolve the deep-seated contradictions and problems hindering the development of Hong Kong and Macao”; Vice President Chen Shaobo also emphasized that civil servants are the “key players” in upholding the executive-led system.
These remarks serve as a call to action and, more importantly, a show of support for the SAR government. Nearly thirty years after Hong Kong’s return to China, the transition “from chaos to order” has been achieved, but the shift “from order to prosperity” has hit a bottleneck. The bottleneck lies not in political loyalty, but in the effectiveness of governance. The central government has already set the stage; the test now is whether senior officials of the Hong Kong government dare to step out of their comfort zones and truly take charge.
The problem is that some high-ranking officials are still caught up in the illusion of “procedural compliance.”
The case recently exposed by Legislative Council member Leung Man-kwong is a vivid example: regarding a dangerous metal scaffold and old water pipes in Yau Tsim Mong, complaints were filed from August through October, yet departments passed the buck back and forth, with no one taking responsibility. This is not an isolated incident; it is the inevitable result of the “eight-tier approval chain” and a “risk-averse culture.” When high-ranking officials adopt “do nothing, make no mistakes” as their philosophy for survival, frontline civil servants become trapped in a sea of paperwork, and the public’s urgent needs and concerns are completely buried in the cracks between file folders.
"Someone in the thick of it" is not the person passing the flower in the "Pass the Flower" game.
Director Xia Baolong’s close linkage of “breaking down entrenched vested interests” with “executive-led governance” is highly significant. Consider Hong Kong’s fiscal structure: civil service salaries and pensions amount to nearly 170 billion yuan annually, while liabilities for pensions under the old system total as much as 967.6 billion yuan. When rigid expenditures lock up resources, where is there room for grassroots welfare and youth development? On the other hand, the ratio of the head of the Food and Environmental Hygiene Department to rank-and-file staff is a staggering 1:95. A single frontline worker faces nearly 100 assigned tasks, while the senior management structure is layered upon layer. If this isn’t a misallocation of resources, what is? If this isn’t the entrenchment of vested interests, what is?
As I understand it, senior officials are reluctant to take bold, sweeping actions not only because they are constrained by vested interests, but also because they fear the accountability pressures that come with the notion that “the more you do, the more mistakes you make.” Therefore, to break down these barriers, a two-pronged approach is essential.
On the one hand, the government should implement “efficiency-based restructuring” by conducting an independent review to eliminate redundant senior leadership positions and redirect resources to the front lines; it should also establish a “review of senior officials’ compensation standards” to address public grievances through transparent procedures. On the other hand, the government must establish a “mistake-tolerance mechanism” and foster a culture of “immunity for innovation.” We cannot allow officials who dare to take responsibility to “sweat and shed tears,” nor can we allow those who adhere to the “do nothing, make no mistakes” mentality to remain comfortably in high positions.
Director Xia Baolong stated frankly that the administration-led model in the Special Administrative Region “has not always run smoothly,” and the lessons learned have been profound. Why are these lessons so profound? Because when the governing team loses touch with the grassroots, even the best system is nothing more than a castle in the air.
The author must point out that the window of opportunity to transition from governance to prosperity will not remain open forever. The central government has already addressed the SAR government’s concerns and offered its support and encouragement; senior officials of the Hong Kong government must set aside the burden of being mere “procedural executors” and demonstrate the resolve of “head of the household.” To break down barriers, we must first address the misallocation of resources within the system; to join hands with the grassroots, we must first confront the reality of the 1:95 ratio. The data speaks for itself—reform must be implemented without delay.


