From “Moving into New Homes in Three Years” to an Ambitious Target System: Rebuilding the Five-Year Plan Through System Resilience

By Dr. Chen Chengyu

“A three-year wait for public housing” was once a solemn promise made to the public in the early days following Hong Kong’s handover. In 1997, Tung Chee-hwa, the first Chief Executive, explicitly stated in his Policy Address that the average waiting time for public housing would be reduced to three years. Driven by this policy, the waiting time briefly dropped to a historic low of 2.1 years in 2003. However, as the focus of subsequent housing policies shifted and land supply remained insufficient, this commitment gradually became nothing more than a slogan. Today, “Hong Kong’s First Five-Year Plan” sets the target for the comprehensive public housing waiting time in the 2030/31 fiscal year at “less than four years,” which still falls significantly short of the original commitment of “three years.”

This is not just a housing issue; it is a microcosm of the entire Five-Year Plan target system. Of the 22 key indicators, only 5 are binding, while the remaining 17 are aspirational. If the Five-Year Plan is to truly become a hard constraint driving Hong Kong’s high-quality development, it must start with public housing, confront vested interests head-on, and use systemic resilience to rebuild a set of ambitious yet achievable goals.

I. In-Depth Analysis: Insufficient Systemic Resilience and the Political Economy of Reform

The chronic lag in public housing supply is not simply due to a lack of land or funding. Brownfield sites in the New Territories hold enormous potential, and the Modular and Prefabricated Construction (MiC) method can already reduce construction timelines to 10 to 12 months. The real problem lies in three interlocking bottlenecks: the procedural chain, the vested-interest chain, and the implementation chain. It takes five to eight years for land to be converted from “raw land” to “developed land,” and interdepartmental coordination is inefficient; there is a lack of an effective turnover mechanism for public housing; high-income households are reluctant to move out, resulting in units that only come in but never go out. Ultimately, this stems from insufficient system resilience—the institutional framework is unable to self-diagnose and quickly rectify issues.

No reform can avoid resistance from those with vested interests. Brownfield development involves a power struggle between local elites and landowners; well-off public housing tenants have the ability to mobilize votes; while the civil service system is characterized by institutional incentives to avoid risk—as reflected in the mindset that “holding office involves risk, but working for a major organization carries much lower risk.” Without transitional arrangements and room for error, even the best cross-departmental platform will inevitably devolve into a situation where “where there is policy from above, there are countermeasures below.”

II. The Key to Breaking the Deadlock: Restructuring the Indicator System to Resolve the “Constraint Paradox”

The government has recognized that land acquisition, legislation, and funding are external variables. If the “comprehensive waiting time”—which is influenced by macroeconomic factors and population mobility—is directly set as a binding indicator, it could easily lead to falsification of data to meet targets, reckless rushing of projects, or a sacrifice of housing quality. Therefore, the author advocates clearly distinguishing between two types of indicators in next year’s updated five-year plan:

· Process indicators (set as mandatory): reduction rate in government-controlled approval times, volume of land released, and MiC prefabrication rate. For example: Complete the pilot program for the cross-departmental command platform by 2027; fully implement MiC 3.0 by 2028.

· Outcome Indicators (set as aspirational targets and mandatory minimum thresholds): Set “reducing the construction period to 3.5 years by 2028 and to 3 years by 2030” as phased targets, and establish corresponding “quality thresholds and community amenity standards” to ensure that meeting these targets does not compromise the quality of housing.

III. Five Major Systemic Reforms: From Vision to a Commitment-Based Roadmap

First, establish a cross-departmental housing supply command platform. Set up a unified data hub for public housing supply to break down bureaucratic barriers.

[Risks and Mitigation]: Data silos across departments are the biggest obstacle. It is recommended to begin with a pilot program in the Northern Metropolitan Area, using a “data-for-resources” incentive mechanism to break the deadlock, and to introduce third-party audits to ensure data accuracy.

*

Second, introduce a dynamic demand early-warning mechanism. Establish a health early-warning system that includes indicators such as the number of applications and the rental burden ratio for private housing, review housing construction targets annually, and proactively adjust the pace of land releases.

[Risks and Mitigation]: Early warning mechanisms may fail due to data lags; it is necessary to collaborate with the Census Bureau and research institutions at various universities to establish a rolling model of population and housing demand.

Third, leveraging technology to enhance housing construction and the approval process. Fully implementing MiC 3.0 to increase the prefabrication rate to 90 percent; introducing an AI-assisted approval system to shorten application and approval times.

[Risks and Mitigation]: Construction technology involves high initial costs and requires overcoming operational inertia among frontline staff. It is recommended to establish an incubation center for housing innovation and technology, providing subsidies and training.

Fourth, reform the housing transfer mechanism and install elevators in public housing. Increase the additional rent for high-income households to a maximum of 4.5 times the standard rate and set a clear timeline for their relocation; provide low-interest first-time homebuyer loans for young people (subject to stress testing and a 60 percent loan-to-value cap); establish a special fund to repurchase 1,000 to 1,500 vacant units; prioritize the development of 500 hectares of brownfield sites to provide at least 15,000 units by 2028; and establish an expedited relocation channel with a 6-month relocation period for subdivided flat tenants.

[Risks and Mitigation Measures]: The implementation of policies for high-net-worth individuals should include a three-year transition period and gradually decreasing subsidies to avoid a situation where those who make the most noise get priority; youth loans must guard against systemic financial risks.

Fifth, diversified financing and the public-private boundary. Establish a special housing fund, issue REITs and special-purpose bonds, with the goal of achieving a 1:5 leverage ratio.

[Risks and Mitigation]: Caution must be exercised when drawing lessons from Israel’s Yozma program. Yozma is a venture capital initiative that seeks financial returns; public housing, on the other hand, is a social safety net that aims to ensure social stability. When applying the “government-catalyzed, market-led” model to public housing, the nature of the returns must be clearly defined. It is recommended to first conduct a pilot program in the Northern Metropolis, designing mechanisms for risk-sharing and an orderly government exit while clearly defining the boundaries between the public and private sectors.

IV. Cross-Disciplinary Collaboration: Limited Extension Centered on Institutional Resilience

Public housing reform is just the beginning. The Five-Year Plan also calls for more ambitious goals in areas such as innovation and technology, the Northern Metropolis, healthcare, green initiatives, finance, and talent development; however, rather than spreading efforts evenly, these efforts should be guided by the principle of “institutional resilience”:

· Innovation and Technology, and Shenzhen-Hong Kong Innovation and Technology Park: Incorporate the commercialization rate of university research outcomes into KPIs; complete the pilot program for the negative list on cross-border data flow in the Hetao area by 2030; and introduce a new indicator for the production utilization rate of industrial land in the Shenzhen-Hong Kong Innovation and Technology Park.

· Healthcare and Green Development: The target for the number of doctors per 1,000 people has been raised to 2.6–2.8; measures will be implemented to reduce waiting times for new specialty clinic appointments; the share of zero-carbon energy will be increased to 35% in the medium term; and a mutual recognition mechanism for green hydrogen certification among Guangdong, Hong Kong, and Macao will be established by 2028.

· Finance and Talent: Transition from rule-arbitrageurs to rule-makers; take the lead in establishing no fewer than three international financial standards by 2030; raise the target for non-local students to between 120,000 and 150,000; and introduce a new metric for the retention rate of high-end talent.

V. Conclusion: Regaining Public Confidence Through Political Courage and Systemic Resilience

Next year will be a pivotal year for the implementation of the Five-Year Plan. The author hopes that, when updating the plan, the government will establish a rolling mid-term review mechanism to dynamically adjust targets each year in light of changes in population, the economy, and technology, and will set up a public oversight platform to publish data—such as waiting times, housing construction progress, and approval compression rates—on a quarterly basis.

A clear timeline should be established: Complete the pilot program for the cross-departmental command platform by 2027; reduce the waiting time to 3.5 years and fully implement MiC 3.0 by 2028; In 2029, the relocation schedule for high-income households will be fully implemented; in 2030, the waiting time will be reduced to 3 years, and the mid-term evaluation of the Five-Year Plan will be completed.

Moving into a new home within three years is not a distant fantasy, but a goal that can be achieved through systematic and resilient reforms. Hong Kong does not lack land, capital, or talent; what it lacks are institutional frameworks that facilitate the seamless integration of technology and the market, a culture of execution characterized by a willingness to take responsibility and act proactively, and—most of all—the political courage to confront vested interests and overcome resistance to reform.

True system resilience lies not only in passively plugging loopholes, but also in proactively building a governance system capable of self-diagnosis, self-repair, and continuous evolution. “Moving into new homes within three years” is not just a slogan, but a litmus test for the effectiveness of government governance; ambitious targets are not a numbers game, but a hard constraint that tests whether the Five-Year Plan is truly results-oriented. Only by restructuring supply chains with a mindset of systemic resilience, breaking down departmental barriers through data-driven approaches, revitalizing circulation mechanisms through institutional innovation, and resolving resistance to reform with political wisdom can citizens regain their confidence in the future.

(The views expressed in this article are solely those of the author.)

Scroll to Top