By Dr. Chen Chengyu
The Hong Shui Kiu/Ha Tsuen project—the first pilot development zone under the Northern Metropolis initiative—recently successfully completed its bidding process. A consortium comprising six companies—including China Overseas, Sino Land, and JD.com—successfully won the bid. The project involves a total investment of approximately HK$16.8 billion and is expected to create more than 6,000 jobs. Officials described the outcome of this bidding process as a “win-win” situation: on the one hand, it attracts private-sector capital to the project, and on the other, it alleviates the financial burden on the government resulting from direct cash investment.
However, the development of the Northern Metropolis has never been merely a matter of land grading and building construction; it is also a challenge to Hong Kong’s overall governance systemSystem ResilienceA comprehensive stress test. System resilience refers to the ability of an institutional framework to uphold its core public objectives—even in the face of external shocks such as a sudden surge in construction volume, structural constraints resulting from an aging population, and institutional friction caused by delays in policy updates—while adapting and evolving continuously amid these challenges. Viewed from this perspective, behind these impressive bidding results lie several profound signals that cannot be ignored and deserve careful scrutiny by society.
Differences in Market Participation: Avoiding the Risk of a Monolithic Capital Structure
Looking back at the initial call for expressions of interest for the Hung Shui Kiu area, a total of 22 expressions of interest were received, with more than 60 percent coming from Hong Kong-funded enterprises; however, by the time the formal bidding stage began, only two bids were submitted, with only two of them from Hong Kong-funded companies. The significant disparity between the number of expressions of interest and the number of bids reflects the local business community’s generally cautious and reserved attitude toward large-scale district development.
The consortium that won the bid this time features a “five mainland, one Hong Kong” composition, with five state-owned enterprises and companies with mainland Chinese ownership, and only one Hong Kong-owned firm. This raises a systemic concern: over-reliance on a single type of capital in development is, in itself, a structural vulnerability. With the Fanling North New Development Area expected to launch its tender process by the end of this year, if subsequent projects continue to be dominated by state-owned enterprises, the market’s diversity and resilience in the Northern Metropolis will face a severe test.
To unleash more market forces, the government could consider establishingTiered Participation Mechanism...allowing developers to participate in district development through a modular approach. Breaking down mega-projects into separate segments lowers the capital threshold, reduces risk exposure, and eases time-to-completion pressures for individual consortia, thereby giving more local enterprises—both large and small—the opportunity to participate. This enriches the diversity of market participation and prevents large-scale development from becoming overly concentrated among a handful of consortia.
Industrial Layout: From Attracting Leading Companies to Building a Collaborative Industrial Ecosystem
JD.com Group’s decision to establish a modern logistics center in Hongshuiqiao is undoubtedly a positive breakthrough in industrial investment promotion. However, the arrival of a leading company does not mean that a complete industrial ecosystem has been formed. The real challenge for Beidu’s development lies not in “attracting large enterprises,” but inMoving beyond simply attracting investment to building an industrial ecosystem。
The government should take the lead in establishing a collaboration platform to facilitate connections between leading enterprises that have set up operations here and local Hong Kong small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) as well as various professional service sectors, thereby fostering collaboration across the upstream and downstream industrial chains and building a mutually beneficial and symbiotic network between large enterprises and SMEs. If we rely solely on individual enterprises to operate independently, even with major projects coming in, they are likely to become isolated industrial nodes, making it difficult to drive widespread local industrial value-added growth and create employment spillover effects.
Labor Supply: Breaking the Cycle of Subcontracting in the Construction Industry and Promoting a Closed-Loop Talent System
Ning Hanhao, Secretary for Development, has long acknowledged that as the construction of the Northern Metropolis enters its peak phase, the talent shortage in the construction industry will become increasingly acute. The practical constraints are very clear: the average age of construction workers in Hong Kong has reached 46 to 50 years, and the number of newly registered skilled workers over the past five years has dropped by nearly 30 percent compared to a decade ago. The rate at which the workforce is being replenished is far from keeping pace with the demand curve driven by the expansion of construction projects.
The Hung Shui Kiu project will create 6,000 jobs, but without a talent development system that keeps pace with the construction schedule, these new positions will only intensify the vicious competition among companies vying for talent, rather than truly alleviating the labor shortage. This precisely illustrates the “compensatory response” phenomenon I have previously described: when one part of a system is under immense pressure, other segments are forced to operate at full capacity, which creates hidden risks that accumulate over the long term.
There are already exemplary practices in the industry that serve as useful references. Chuang Junyue, Chairman of Junjie Group, explained that the group builds long-term talent reserves through a “one-to-two, two-to-four” apprenticeship system, promotes workers to take on multiple roles, and encourages them to obtain multiple professional licenses. As a result, the average age of its workers remains at 42. Building on this private-sector experience, the government can collaborate with the Construction Industry Council to establish a comprehensive, cross-trade skills certification system: from the design of vocational education curricula and investment in continuing on-the-job training to the standardization of multi-industry, multi-skill certifications—these three elements should be interlinked to form a closed-loop system. While infrastructure development takes precedence, workforce upskilling must proceed in tandem; otherwise, even the most ambitious blueprint will harbor latent risks of future systemic failure.
Fiscal Financing: Establish Stress Tests and Ensure PPPs “Borrow Brainpower” Rather Than Just “Borrow Money”
To fund large-scale infrastructure projects, the government has raised the borrowing ceiling for two bond programs to HK$900 billion; In May of this year, the issuance of a combined HK$27.6 billion in green bonds and infrastructure bonds was oversubscribed by approximately 8.6 times, reflecting the market’s confidence in Hong Kong’s infrastructure debt.
However, looking ahead to the next five to six years, Beijing’s potential expenditures could reach as high as 360 billion Hong Kong dollars. Adopting a systemic perspective, society needs to ask itself rationally: If global interest rates fluctuate or the external geopolitical landscape shifts, will existing financing channels remain accessible?
There are two specific recommendations in this regard. First, the government should establishFiscal Stress Testing Mechanism... Regularly simulate extreme scenarios—such as an economic downturn or a sharp contraction in land sale revenue—to assess the capacity of public finances and build risk buffers in advance. Second, the Development Bureau should take the lead in establishing a dedicated PPP office to uniformly develop contract templates, standardize risk assessment processes, and establish a clear dispute resolution mechanism. It is essential to recognize that the core value of the PPP model is by no means simply borrowing from the market to cover expenditures, but rather “borrowing expertise”—that is, achieving a systemic balance between the commercial efficiency mindset of the private market and the long-term interests of public development.
Institutional Innovation: Moving from a “Bonsai” to a “Forest,” Balancing Development Pace and Social Harmony
The “Northern Metropolis Development Bill” has been submitted to the Legislative Council for its first reading. This marks the first time Hong Kong has enacted legislation specifically for the development of a single region; the bill also proposes introducing a “whitelist” in the Hong Kong Park of the Lok Ma Chau Loop to facilitate cross-border personnel movement. However, the Hong Kong Park covers only 87 hectares, an area far smaller than the entire Northern Metropolis. If these institutional breakthroughs are limited to specific locations, they will amount to nothing more than ornamental “bonsai” rather than a “forest” capable of benefiting the entire region.
To extend the benefits of the system from isolated cases to a broader scale, the author once again recommends establishing a body directly led by the Chief Executive,Northern Metropolitan Area Development Authority...and endow it with three core functions: comprehensive planning and coordination, cross-regional and cross-border coordination, and the implementation of innovative regulatory measures. The “Certification and Service System for Specialized, Refined, Distinctive, and Innovative Enterprises” could first be piloted in the Hetao area, after which facilitative arrangements—such as personnel clearance, data flow, material allocation, and cross-border capital flows—could be gradually extended to the entire Beidu region.
Just as important as institutional reform is striking a balance between the pace of development and social harmony. During the second phase of land acquisition in Hung Shui Kiu in June 2026, more than 40 households were unable to secure relocation due to eligibility issues, reflecting the complex challenges that still exist in the land acquisition process. The Chinese General Chamber of Commerce also cautioned that ancestral hall lands involve profound clan histories and intricate legal relationships, and that streamlining procedures must not be rushed. How to properly address the rights and interests of various stakeholders while advancing development will test the government’s governance wisdom.
The challenges facing the Northern Metropolitan Area are scattered across various aspects: fluctuations in market confidence, a fragile industrial ecosystem, concerns about a generational gap in the workforce, risks in public finances, and bottlenecks in promoting institutional innovation. It is not alarming for gaps and problems to emerge during the development process; what matters is whether the system allows sufficient room for these issues to be identified, discussed, and resolved.
Over the next five years, the capital will enter a decisive phase, and society must continue to grapple with three key questions: How can we uphold fiscal discipline while ensuring the pace of development? How can we make effective use of market forces while safeguarding the public interest? How can we accelerate development while resolving social conflicts? Financial Secretary Paul Chan Mo-po has called on the public to actively participate in the public consultations on the Five-Year Plan and the Policy Address, a view with which I wholeheartedly agree.
The Northern Metropolis has never been merely a government project; it is a shared endeavor for the entire society. Only by refusing to settle for mere tender results and instead turning to ongoing, systematic analysis; and by moving beyond one-sided official assessments to expand the participation of diverse stakeholders—can this grand blueprint truly be transformed into solid steps for Hong Kong’s journey from stability to prosperity.


