By Dr. Chen Chengyu
The spatial pattern of Hong Kong’s housing supply has long been characterized by a fundamental distortion: large tracts of land in urban areas have been allocated for private housing, while public housing and Home Ownership Scheme units have been forced to relocate to remote areas. Low-income residents have been forced to move to outlying areas of the New Territories with poor transportation access and inadequate amenities, facing high daily commuting costs and a breakdown in community support networks. This spatial inequality—characterized by “private housing in the city center and public housing on the periphery”—is one of the deepest-rooted structural contradictions underlying Hong Kong’s housing crisis.
New private housing developments over the next decade should be concentrated in the Northern Metropolis rather than scattered throughout Hong Kong. This is not about “driving out private housing,” but rather about restoring private housing to its proper role—to develop in tandem with industry, transportation, and the community on this new land in the Northern Metropolis. The urban core, meanwhile, should be reserved for low-income residents, allowing them to live and work peacefully in the neighborhoods they know well.
I. Urban land should be prioritized for public housing
Land is scarce in Hong Kong’s urban areas, and every plot of land represents a trade-off in terms of opportunity cost. If new private housing developments over the next decade are concentrated in the northern districts, urban land can be freed up and prioritized for the construction of public rental housing and Home Ownership Scheme units. The implications of this shift are far-reaching: an increase in the supply of public rental housing in urban areas is expected to shorten waiting times; low-income residents can remain in their familiar neighborhoods, making it more convenient to find employment, attend school, and receive medical care; public housing sites would no longer be forced to the “periphery,” thereby improving living standards and dignity. More importantly, this would break the long-standing stigma that “public housing equals remote locations,” allowing public housing to return to its rightful place.
However, this logic requires quantitative support. New land available for development in urban areas is already scarce; much of the private housing in these areas comes from the redevelopment of old neighborhoods and land-use rezoning, rather than from brand-new, unused land. Even if the government were to stop granting new government-owned land for private housing in urban areas, existing redevelopment projects would continue to generate a supply of private housing. Therefore, the principle of “prioritizing public housing on urban land” cannot be achieved overnight but must be implemented gradually through planning-led approaches, adjustments to redevelopment policies, and dynamic regulation of the public-private housing ratio. According to the Long-Term Housing Strategy, the public-private housing ratio for the next decade will be 70 to 30; If new private housing were concentrated in the Northern District, the land released in urban areas could theoretically provide an additional 20 to 30 percent of land for public housing, with the exact amount depending on the pace of old district redevelopment and the progress of land rezoning. Although this goal cannot be achieved in the short term, the direction must be clear.
II. Beijing Has Unique Advantages for Absorbing the Private Housing Market
Beidu is not a “remote area,” but rather a strategic growth hub for Hong Kong’s future development. Its advantages include:
Abundant Land Supply: New development areas such as San Tin Science Park, Hung Shui Kiu, and Kwu Tung North provide a large supply of developed land. According to the 2026 Policy Address, the Northern Metropolis is projected to produce approximately 900 hectares of developed land and about 70,000 residential units from 2026/27 to 2030/31, indicating immense potential for private housing development.
Industrial Support: The establishment of industries such as innovation and technology, logistics, and professional services will create job opportunities. The Shenzhen-Hong Kong Science and Technology Innovation Cooperation Zone in Hetao, Xintian Science and Technology City, and the Shaling Data Park will form industrial clusters, eliminating the need for residents to commute long distances.
Transportation Infrastructure: The Northern Loop Line, the Hong Kong–Shenzhen Western Railway, and the Northern Highway are gradually being completed. The Kwu Tung Station on the East Rail Line is scheduled for completion in 2027 and will become the MTR’s 100th station; the Hung Shui Kiu Station on the Tuen Ma Line is expected to be completed in 2030; and the main line and branch line of the Northern Link are scheduled to open simultaneously by 2034.
Institutional Innovation: The Northern Metropolis can take the lead in piloting new models such as “area-based development” and “premium payments based on actual land value” to reduce development costs. The Hung Shui Kiu area development project was awarded in August 2026 at a winning bid of 1.03 billion yuan, marking the Northern Metropolis’s first area-based tender project; Ning Hanhao, Secretary for Development, stated that efforts are underway to launch the tender for the Fanling North area by the end of 2026, which is expected to provide approximately 4,200 residential units.
However, not all land in Beidou is suitable for private residential development. Core innovation and technology districts, such as Hetao and Xintian Technology City, may be better suited for the development of talent apartments and subsidized housing rather than purely private residential buildings. A mixed-use model may be preferable: the Northern Metropolis could pilot “public-private mixed” communities, allowing people from different income groups to live together and avoiding a repeat of “segregated” planning.
III. Employment Center: Private Residential Buildings in Beidu Must Not Become “Dormitory Towns”
If residents of private housing in North City work in Central or Kowloon East, their commutes will still be lengthy. North City must develop its own employment centers; otherwise, residents of private housing will still be forced to endure long commutes. It is recommended to establish a clear “North District employment self-sufficiency rate” indicator—for example, ensuring that 50 percent of the working population is employed within the North District by 2036. Land for industries such as innovation and technology, logistics, and professional services should be developed in conjunction with residential land to ensure a “work-life balance.” At the same time, North City should develop a diverse range of industries to avoid over-reliance on innovation and technology, enabling residents with different skill sets to find employment opportunities within the district. If the employment self-sufficiency rate falls below 40 percent for two consecutive years, a mechanism for adjusting industrial land use should be triggered, converting a portion of residential land to industrial use to address the risk of becoming a “dormitory town” at its source.
IV. Spatial Division of Labor: A Dual-Track System with Public Sector Operations in the City and Private Sector Operations in the Northern Metropolis
It is recommended that a clear division of spatial roles be established for the next decade:
Urban Areas: Land should be allocated primarily for public housing and Home Ownership Scheme units. Not all land in urban areas is suitable for public housing construction; some sites are subject to constraints such as environmental impact assessments, transportation issues, and community opposition. However, the policy direction should be clear: land in urban areas should be used primarily for public housing, with private housing serving as a supplement.
Beidu: New private residential developments are concentrated here, complementing the innovation and technology industries and transportation infrastructure to create a modern new district that is “ideal for business, living, and tourism.” Beidu could pilot a “mixed-income” community, allowing people from different income groups to live together and avoid repeating the mistakes of “segregated” planning.
This division of roles is not “segregation,” but rather “each in its proper place.” Public housing in the city center provides affordable housing for low-income residents, while private housing in Beidu allows the middle class and professionals to buy homes; the two are complementary rather than competitive.
V. Supporting Infrastructure: Without These, Beidou’s Private Housing Will Simply Become an “Island”
Industry First: Private housing must be developed in tandem with industrial projects. If Beidou consists solely of residential areas without job opportunities, residents will still have to commute long distances, turning it into a “dormitory town.” It is recommended that land designated for industries such as innovation and technology, logistics, and professional services be developed in conjunction with residential land.
Accelerating Transportation Infrastructure Development: The Northern Ring Line, the Hong Kong–Shenzhen Western Railway, and the Northern Highway must be completed simultaneously with residential developments. If transportation infrastructure lags behind, residents will face high commuting costs, and the appeal of private housing will be significantly diminished.
Comprehensive community amenities: Schools, hospitals, shopping centers, and recreational and sports facilities must be planned in tandem with residential development. We recommend adopting the “15-minute living circle” concept and establishing “Beidu Community Standards” to ensure that community amenities meet the same standards as those in the city center. If community facilities are not completed on schedule, the move-in date for residential units should be postponed accordingly to prevent residents from moving into an “isolated community.”
Demand Management: As the supply of private housing in Beidu increases, demand must be managed in tandem. We recommend establishing the “Beidu Housing Health Index” to dynamically adjust the pace of supply in line with the economic cycle and housing price levels. When the vacancy rate exceeds a certain threshold for two consecutive quarters, an automatic adjustment mechanism should be triggered to reallocate a portion of private housing land for subsidized sale housing. This is a “dynamic adjustment” mechanism that allows the system to self-correct in the face of disruptions, rather than waiting until market imbalances arise to take corrective action.
VI. Political-Economic Obstacles and Transition Planning
Real estate developers: With a decrease in land available for private residential development in urban areas, developers may oppose this. The more fundamental issue is that the scarcity of urban land for private residential development is precisely what keeps prices high; increasing supply in the northern part of the city would drive down private residential prices citywide, and “profit-sharing” may not be enough to compensate for the decline in the value of existing assets.
It is recommended to proceed in phases: In Phase I (2026–2028), pilot “public-private mixed-use” communities in the Northern District first, with the Northern District accounting for 50 percent of new private housing supply. Some prime urban plots will still be reserved for private housing to avoid market volatility; Phase Two (2029–2031) will increase the proportion in North City to 70 percent, while private housing land in the city center will be gradually converted to public housing; Phase Three (2032–2036) will raise the proportion in North City to 90 percent, with only a small amount of private housing retained in the city center for urban renewal and special projects. At the same time, “development deadline clauses” and “price control mechanisms” will be established to ensure that private housing is completed on time and priced reasonably. For private housing owners in the urban core affected by the increased supply in North City, tax incentives or asset conversion arrangements will be provided to resolve resistance through a “time-for-space” approach.
Downtown Property Owners: With the supply of private residential units in downtown areas decreasing, current homeowners may be concerned about asset depreciation. It is recommended to implement “asset isolation” arrangements—such as separating the markets for new and existing private residential properties—to avoid direct competition. Specifically, the Executive Condominium (EC) model in Singapore could serve as a reference: new private residential developments in the North District could pilot a “price and purchase cap” model, establishing eligibility criteria and resale restrictions; the secondary market for private residential properties in the city center would remain a free market, but an “additional stamp duty for non-first-time buyers” would be introduced to curb speculation. At the same time, a “price monitoring index for downtown pre-owned private residential properties” should be established to automatically trigger demand-management measures in the event of abnormal price fluctuations.
Civil Service System: Interdepartmental coordination involves the Development Bureau, the Housing Bureau, the Planning Department, the Transport and Logistics Bureau, and others; without “innovation immunity” and cross-departmental KPIs, it will be difficult to implement reforms. It is recommended to establish a “Northern Metropolis Housing Supply Command Platform,” personally overseen by the Chief Secretary for Administration, to incorporate the “interdepartmental approval compression rate” into performance evaluations and create room for error, thereby avoiding a risk-averse culture where “doing nothing is the safe bet.”
Fiscal Challenges: The reduction in urban land available for sale to private developers will directly impact government revenue. It is recommended to fill the gap through diversified financing: establish a dedicated housing fund, issue real estate investment trusts (REITs) and special-purpose bonds, with the goal of achieving a 1:5 leverage ratio; Drawing on the “government-catalyzed, market-led” logic of Israel’s Yozma Program, the government should contribute capital as a parent fund to leverage private capital for construction, and establish a “self-exit mechanism” to allow government funds to exit in an orderly manner once projects reach maturity. At the same time, long-term capital such as insurance funds and family offices should be guided to participate in the construction of the Northern Capital to alleviate fiscal pressure.
VII. International Context: The Institutional Spirit of the Division of Labor in Space
Singapore: Public housing is concentrated in new towns, while private housing is concentrated in the core areas, creating a spatial pattern where “public housing takes the lead and private housing plays a supporting role.” HDB housing accommodates about 80 percent of Singapore’s population, while private housing accounts for only about 20 percent. It must be acknowledged that Singapore’s success relies on compulsory land acquisition, statutory rental rates, and a nationwide Central Provident Fund system—none of which Hong Kong possesses. However, the value of this analogy lies not in copying the system verbatim, but in learning from its “spirit”: government-led land supply, a clear public-private housing ratio, and a smooth housing ladder. Although Hong Kong lacks the conditions for compulsory land acquisition, it can gradually establish similar control through models such as “zonal development” and “premium payments based on actual land value.”
Shenzhen: New towns such as Longhua and Bao’an are absorbing the population spillover from the city center, while simultaneously developing industries to avoid becoming “dormitory towns.” Shenzhen’s “work-live balance” planning is worth emulating for Beijing.
Tokyo: Tama New Town uses railways as its backbone, promoting the simultaneous development of industry and housing to achieve “work-life proximity.” The experience of Tama New Town shows that transportation infrastructure and industrial support must be established first; otherwise, a new town will merely become a “dormitory town.”
VIII. Social Consensus and Expectation Management
Concentrating new private housing in Beidu requires simultaneously managing public expectations. How can we avoid the perception that “private housing in Beidu equals remote and second-rate”? How can we ensure that community amenities in Northern District private housing match those in the city center? It is recommended to establish “Northern District Community Standards” to ensure that schools, hospitals, shopping centers, and recreational and sports facilities are completed simultaneously with residential units. When the first batch of Northern District private housing is completed, high-quality schools, hospitals, and shopping centers should be introduced at the same time to dispel prejudices through a “demonstration effect.” At the same time, through public consultation and transparency mechanisms, the public should be helped to understand the necessity of the reform and the transitional arrangements. The government should publish quarterly data on the progress of private housing supply in the Northern Metropolis, the employment self-sufficiency rate, and the completion status of community amenities, allowing the public to monitor these developments in real time.
IX. Conclusion: From “Spatial Inequality” to “Spatial Justice”
For a long time, the spatial pattern of Hong Kong’s housing supply has been characterized by “private housing in the city center and public housing on the outskirts,” resulting in severe spatial inequality. Concentrating new private housing development over the next decade in the North District and prioritizing land in the city center for public housing represents a fundamental correction to this pattern.
This is not about “driving out private housing,” but rather about restoring private housing to its proper role: developing in tandem with industry, transportation, and communities on this new land in Beidu, and serving the homeownership needs of the middle class and professionals. The city center, meanwhile, should be reserved for low-income residents, allowing them to live and work happily in the communities they know well.
The author believes that “true system resilience lies not merely in passively plugging loopholes, but in proactively building a governance system capable of self-diagnosis, self-repair, and continuous evolution.” The spatial restructuring of housing supply is the ultimate test of this logic. Only by restructuring the spatial division of labor with a mindset of system resilience, unlocking the potential of Beijing through institutional innovation, and overcoming resistance to reform with political wisdom can we restore citizens’ confidence in the future.
(The views expressed in this article are solely those of the author.)


